My Moment with Bhutto: A reminiscence of the leader, who was assassinated on December 27
December 29th, 2007
By Asma Hasan
During my sophomore year of college in 1995, I armed myself with a press pass from a small Pakistani-American newspaper and played hooky to see Benazir Bhutto on her official U.S. state visit. Bhutto was a divisive figure for Pakistanis, many of whom viewed her as just another corrupt leader. But seeing her speak at Princeton University that day, I found myself unexpectedly growing proud. She talked about the 
Prime Minsiter Benazir Bhutto - related articlesCandlelight vigil honours Benazir
Pakistan’s flawed and feudal princess Pakistan in talks on Bhutto probe
Bhutto ‘killers’ shown in photos
|
reforms she planned, the female police officers the country would hire, the micro-loans that would be made to women’s businesses. She refused to tolerate any criticism of Pakistan, even telling a questioner that Washington, D.C. had a higher crime rate than all of Pakistan (which it did, at the time). The moderator, a white male policy analyst at Princeton’s Woodrow Wilson school, chuckled in delight at her no-holds-barred approach. I saw, for the first time, how female toughness can unexpectedly disarm critics. No one expects a woman, least of all a Muslim woman, to fight back with paralyzing specificity.
After her speech ended, the U.S. Secret Service summarily dismissed every male journalist, leaving me, the sole female, awaiting Bhutto in the hallway. She soon emerged, flanked by additional suited Secret Service agents. She looked just as she did on television: very fair skin (highly prized among Pakistanis), tall, and wearing the ubiquitous headscarf. That head covering was widely believed to be her concession to Pakistan’s mullahs in exchange for their support—one of the things I’d always disliked about her. Walking towards me, she didn’t miss a beat but looked me straight in the eyes; tell your readers, she said, that I’ve come to the U.S. with a message of trade with Pakistan, not aid.
The next moment she arrived at her limo; the Secret Service shoved her in, slammed the doors shut—and they were gone. I stood alone in the space left by Bhutto’s departed car. A phalanx of cheering Princeton students held back by a velvet rope stared at me, no doubt wondering about the identity of this dark-haired girl in the Ann Taylor jumper dress. I held my head up high. Later, when I would defend Bhutto’s tenure, many Pakistanis told me that the reforms I’d so eagerly anticipated never happened; the female police officers were never hired, and the micro-loans for women, with Bhutto’s knowledge, instead went to their husbands. These measures were, at best, sound bites for the West.
Years later, in talking about the books I’d written, radio hosts would comment that I looked like Bhutto. I don’t think I do, but what I think they were trying to say is that we were both forthright, strong Muslim women. As much as everyone likes to complain that Islam gives women an inferior role, Benazir Bhutto disproved that. In doing so, even with her checkered past, she showed me how to shatter the stereotype of what a Muslim woman could be.


Pakistani women light candles in front of a portrait of former Pakistani prime minister Benazir Bhutto during a vigil at her Pakistan Peoples Party office Saturday Dec. 29, 2007 in Lahore, Pakistan. Pakistan says it does not need foreign assistance to investigate Benazir Bhutto’s assassination, despite deepening controversy over how she died and who killed her. (AP Photo/Ed Wray)
The first of the images taken by an amateur at the rally at which Benazir Bhutto died, shows a young man in dark glasses who later appears to shoot at Bhutto. Close behind him, the man in the white scarf (both men circled) was, it is suggested, the suicide bomber (Dawn TV/Reuters)
Lahore archbishop Dr Lawrence Saldanha said Christmas was the biggest and most joyful feast for Christians. The feast celebrated the birth of Jesus Christ in the town of Bethlehem where he was born in a manger, he said. “Shepherds were the first who were given good news by angels about the blessed birth,” he said.